Showing posts with label WW2. Show all posts
Showing posts with label WW2. Show all posts

Friday, January 8, 2016

Closed Season

The year is 1942 and Avi a German Jew gets stranded in a Forest as he tries to escape to Switzerland.  He is rescued by a Fritz a burly local farmer who provides him with a safe refuge in return for Avi's help as he has been running his rather isolated farm with just his wife since his last farmhand had been conscripted for war service.

Emma, his rather uptight wife is opposed to them harboring a Jew and resents Avi's presence but as Fritz constantly reminds her, he is the undisputed boss of their household, so she has no choice than accept it.  Once a week Fritz takes himself off to the village pub and get drunk playing cards with his cronies whilst he ignores Emma so much so that she has never even had a birthday gift from him, that is until Avi comes along.  As he starts to fit into the household, Fritz approaches him with a special request that he expects Avi to agree too in return for being kept safe on the farm.

Fritz is unable to get Emma pregnant and so he very matter-of-factor asks Avi to do it for him so that he can have a son and heir to eventually inherit the farm.  To the surly farmer who has no time for emotions or feelings, this is just like a business transaction where everyone will get what they want. Emma however, is extremely reluctant to go along and initially just goes through the motions every time Avi tries to keep his end of the bargain. However as up till now all she has in the way of sex is her older husband's clumsy perfunctory attempts, she soon warms up to Avi's visits when she discovers that making love can be really enjoyable.  
She quickly gets pregnant but keeps the news from Fritz so she can continuing making out with Avi who by now she is totally besotted with.  He is also really getting into, so much so that even Fritz starts to notice the different atmosphere at home.  That however will soon come to a very sudden halt when the local Nazi boss turns up and captures Avi and hauls him off.

We learn all this in  a series of flashbacks as the story is told 18 years later in Israel by a reluctant Avi who has been confronted by a young German man who has turned up on his doorstep demanding to know the story of how he came to be his father. Emma has just died and the boy is fulfilling one of her last dying wishes and delivering her note to Avi as she asked. He hopes that this will encourage Avi to come clean about what actually happened during the War, and in fact the letter eventually reveals that they were not exactly all what we had imagined.

This rather odd moving story from German first-time filmmaker Franziska Schlotterer carefully avoids any of the brutality of WW2 by just focusing on this remote part of Germany where the most menacing thing is the nosey bumbling solitary local Nazi official.  It's a tale of pure survival which uncannily turns out in a way that neither man had planned or hoped for even though they both entered into it with totally different intentions. 

Essentially a three-hander, the drama really rests in the hands of Emma (Brigitte Hobmeier) as the obedient wife who up too now never questioned meekly playing her part in this rather feudal system but who now comes alive when she realises that there is more to life than just milking the cows and attending to her husband's every whim in all weathers.  It is a touching performance that adds such an interesting dimension to this very unusual wartime experience of a German jew that panned out so much better than the vast majority.


Monday, December 7, 2015

Phoenix

As WW2 ends German former nightclub singer Nelly is shot as she leaves Auschwitz and her face is severely disfigured. When she arrives back home to a war-torn Berlin, her best friend Lene takes control and whisks her off to see the best plastic surgeon money can buy. With all her Jewish family now dead as a result of the Nazi's genocide, Nelly is a wealthy heiress and the next thing on her schedule after getting a new face, is to stake a claim to her inheritance, and buy an apartment in Palestine and leave Germany for good.

The one fly in the ointment of this plan is that Nelly still wants to find her Aryan piano-player husband Johnny even though Lene tells her that not only is he a no-good philanderer, but it is more than likely he was the one who betrayed her hiding place to the Nazis which led to her being captured and imprisoned.  Undeterred Nelly sets off to search for him in local nightclubs where she is guessing that he may now work, and she finds him surprisingly very easily, but now, down on his luck, he is no longer performing but working as a cleaner who spends his night collecting and washing glasses. 


He fails to recognize her at all, but mistaking her for someone who is just looking for a job, he suggests that as she bears a passing resemblance to 'Nelly his wife'  that she should pretend to be her in order for him to claim her inheritance for himself.  As Johnny sets about training Nelly to impersonate herself he has absolutely no inkling of the truth, or even note that despite the fact he is a real rogue, that she is totally in love with him.

This wonderfully detailed snapshot of a Germany that is just starting to come to terms with the end of the war which has devastated the country and its people themselves is helmed by writer/director Christian Petzold.  It reunites him with his favorite actress Nina Hoss yet again, and together the two of them uniquely capture the essence of a trouble nation trying to get itself together after all of the trauma of war through this very simple story. Hoss gives a powerful performance as Nelly desperately trying to resist getting a new face or a new life as she wants to re-kindle something that was so far from perfect the first time around.  Husband Johnny is played forcefully by Ronald Zehrfeld who also starred with Hoss in Petzold's East German tale "Barbara" that was his country's official submission for a Best Foreign Picture Oscar Nomination in 2012.

The beauty of this particular piece is in the rather triumphant and somewhat unexpected ending which once again simply reminds what an extraordinary team that these three really are.